What Can You Substitute for Eggs in Cookie Batter?

You’re craving the gooey deliciousness of homemade cookies only to realize you’re out of eggs. While eggs are important in baking, there are plenty of pantry substitutes that will get the job done and get your home smelling like freshly made chocolate chip cookies. Whether you include eggs in your diet or not, one or more of the substitutes could work in a pinch to satisfy your cookie craving.

Yogurt

  • Yogurt can be used instead of eggs in your cookie recipe. Since your cookie recipe will already have a leavening agent -- such as baking powder or baking soda -- you can substitute a ¼ cup of yogurt for every 1 medium-sized egg called for in the recipe and there is no need to increase the amount of leavening agent called for in the recipe. Yogurt does have a tangy flavor, so your cookies will take on that flavor during baking.

Bananas

  • Bananas are thick, creamy and can replace eggs in your homemade cookie recipe. You’ll need a ripe banana that easily mashes down. You can replace eggs with bananas by using a ½ of a mashed medium-sized banana for every egg. To keep cookies fluffy rather than dense, add a ¼ tsp. of baking powder for every egg you’re replacing with banana.

Applesauce

  • Applesauce is used in vegan baking because it binds well in drop cookie recipes. Use a ¼ cup of applesauce for every egg your recipe requires. If you’re out of applesauce, use a ¼ cup of pureed fruit for every egg. Avoid overly seasoned applesauces, since these can change the flavor profile of your cookies.

Vegetable Oil

  • If you’re making cake-like cookies -- cookies that are fluffy and light -- you need a substitute that doesn’t deprive your recipe of a leavening agent. Vegetable oil makes a suitable replacement. Use 1 ½ tbsp. of vegetable oil plus 1 ½ tbsp. water and 1 tsp. baking powder for every egg you replace in the recipe.

Tofu

  • Silken, soft tofu can replace eggs in cookie recipes. Before using it, you’ll need to puree the tofu in a blender until it is smooth and creamy. Use a ¼ cup of the pureed tofu for every egg. Your cookies will take on a moister, denser texture and they won’t have the crisp brown edges you’re used to, but the flavor will stay relatively the same.