Can you use tomato or v8 juice to make homemade soup instead of chicken broth?

While tomato or V8 juice can add flavor to soups, they cannot solely replace chicken broth in homemade soups.

Chicken broth provides a distinct richness and savory depth that enhances the overall taste of various soups. It also complements different ingredients like vegetables, meat, and seasonings.

On the other hand, tomato and V8 juice offer their own characteristic flavors. These flavors may work well in specific types of soups, such as Italian-style tomato-based soups. However, using these juices as the sole liquid base might result in a significantly different soup without the traditional qualities of a broth-based soup.