What should you trade for a Shima Longtail on Chicken Smoothie?

- Other uncommon pets, like a Blue and Black Long-Tailed Macaque, a Black Striped Tiger, a Black and Gray Striped Fennec Fox, or a Tan and White Striped Caracal

- Common pets, plus some small adds, like a Green Anole, an Australian Mist Cat, and a rare feather or two

- A pair of popular items, like a Pink Lemonade Pop and a Starry Blue Pop

- A high demand clothing item, like a Purple Party Hat or a Black Tophat