Is it better to resurface the kitchen cabinets or replace them when updating a house?

The decision of whether to resurface or replace kitchen cabinets during a house update depends on various factors, including the condition of the existing cabinets, personal preferences, budget, and overall renovation goals. Here's a comparison of both options:

Resurfacing Kitchen Cabinets:

Advantages:

- Cost-effective: Resurfacing is typically less expensive compared to replacing cabinets. You can save a significant amount of money by keeping the existing cabinet frames and only changing the doors, drawer fronts, and hardware.

- Minimal disruption: Resurfacing requires less time and effort compared to replacement. Since the existing cabinet boxes remain in place, there's no need for extensive demolition or reconstruction.

- Customization: Resurfacing allows you to customize your kitchen cabinets to match your desired style. You can choose different door styles, colors, and finishes to update the look.

- Environmentally friendly: Resurfacing is a more environmentally friendly option as it avoids the waste generated by replacing entire cabinets.

Disadvantages:

- Limited options: Resurfacing may limit your design choices since you're working with the existing cabinet structure. Major structural changes may not be feasible.

- Condition: If your cabinets are severely damaged, warped, or have significant structural issues, resurfacing may not be a suitable option.

- Durability: Resurfaced cabinets may not be as durable as entirely replaced cabinets, especially if the original frames are old or compromised.

Replacing Kitchen Cabinets:

Advantages:

- Complete transformation: Replacing cabinets offers a chance for a complete kitchen makeover. You can choose entirely new cabinet styles, layouts, and materials, giving your kitchen a fresh look.

- Structural changes: Replacing cabinets allows you to make significant structural changes, such as adding or removing cabinets, changing their layout, or incorporating built-in features.

- Improved functionality: New cabinets can provide upgraded features like soft-close drawers, pull-out shelves, and adjustable shelving, enhancing functionality.

- Durability: Brand-new cabinets are built to last and can provide greater durability compared to resurfaced cabinets.

Disadvantages:

- Cost: Replacing kitchen cabinets can be more expensive than resurfacing, especially if you choose higher-end materials and features.

- Disruption: Cabinet replacement involves more extensive work and creates more disruption in the kitchen. It can take longer to complete the project.

- Waste: Replacing cabinets generates more waste since the old ones are discarded.

- Time-consuming: The entire process from planning and design to installation can be time-consuming, potentially delaying other aspects of the renovation.

Ultimately, the choice between resurfacing and replacing kitchen cabinets depends on your specific requirements, budget, and desired outcome. If you're looking for a cost-effective way to update your kitchen with a new look, resurfacing might be a great option. However, if you want to make significant structural changes, improve functionality, or have the budget for a complete kitchen transformation, replacing your cabinets may be the way to go. Consider consulting with a professional kitchen designer or contractor to get expert advice and assess your options based on your specific circumstances.