How to Bake Tilapia & Flounder in a Bag (6 Steps)

Tilapia is so often served in American households that some grocers have difficulty keeping up with demand. So if you’re coming up a little short for your next fish dinner, pair it with a worthy companion: flounder. Both varieties are mild, lean and flaky, with just enough of a difference in texture to give your dinner greater depth and interest. Try baking these so-called “white fish” fillets in a plastic bag to seal in moisture and flavor, and you may not be able to keep up with your family’s demand for an encore of this creative twin billing.

Things You'll Need

  • Meat mallet
  • Knife
  • Seasoning rub
  • Baking dish
  • Instant-read thermometer
  • Wide spatula
  • Lime juice, melted butter and parsley (optional)

Instructions

  1. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Cut the tilapia and flounder into pieces of roughly equal size or cook them whole. Pound a thicker fillet with a meat mallet to ensure that both varieties cook evenly.

  2. Prepare a seasoning rub for the fish, if you like. Sprinkle them with salt, pepper or lemon-pepper seasoning. Or, treat the mild flavor of the tilapia and flounder as a canvas for a zesty flavor punch by mixing vegetable oil, chili powder, garlic powder and salt in a small bowl and mixing. Add a dash of red pepper flakes, if desired. Rub this mixture into the tilapia and flounder.

  3. Place the plastic oven cooking bag in a baking dish. Set the tilapia and flounder inside, positioning slightly larger pieces on the outside perimeter of the bag. Sprinkle a little lime juice over the fish. Use a light touch; fish cooked in a bag need little extra moisture, and you can add more lime juice after the fish is cooked.

  4. Seal the bag with a tie. Make between four to six slits in the bag with a sharp knife so that steam can escape while the fish cooks.

  5. Bake the fish on the lower rack of your oven, where the fish is more likely to get a little brown on the bottom, for between 15 and 20 minutes. Check the internal temperature of both the tilapia and the flounder with an instant-read thermometer to ensure they have reached at least 145 degrees.

  6. Use a wide spatula to remove the fish from the bag. Squirt more lime juice over the fish and top with melted butter and parsley flakes, if you wish.